WIND

Danish dismay as industry clean-up continues

The Danish Energy Agency received no bids in the first phase of its up-to-10GW offshore wind tender, but experts were predicting a shortage of interest due to concerns about support, ownership and the grid.

RICHARD HEAP

December 10, 2024

  • Denmark received no bids in its latest 3GW offshore wind tender
  • Experts previously identified cost, ownership and grid concerns
  • Offshore wind concerns feature in our latest Finance Quarterly
  • AIP’s Domenico Tripodi has warned of “dust under the carpet”

 

Is this the wind industry equivalent of waking up on Christmas Day to find no presents under the tree?

Last Thursday (5th December), the Danish Energy Agency reported that it received no bids in the first phase of its up-to-10GW offshore wind tender.

The agency opened bidding for six sites with the potential for between 6GW and 10GW of offshore wind capacity on 22nd April. That capacity is divided between six projects in four zones, and is being tendered in two phases.

The first phase for the 3GW North Sea zone, which is split into three projects, closed last week with no bids; and the second phase for three sites – Hesselø (800MW-1.2GW), Kattegat (1GW) and Krigers Flak 2 (1GW) – is set to close to bids on 1st April 2025. Due to overplanting rules, the Danish government said these three sites could accommodate up to 10GW in total.

But even that potential was not enough to attract bidders. Lars Aagaard, Denmark’s minister for climate, energy and utilities, said the agency would now enter discussions with the industry to find out why no bidders were interested.

However, he called this a “very disappointing result” and argued that the lack of bids is because “circumstances for offshore wind in Europe have changed significantly in a relatively short time, including large price and interest rate increases”.

That analysis is true to a point, we we can only get so far by blaming inflation and supply chain disruption. These factors have shaped the investment plans of offshore wind developers and supply chain businesses in Europe over the last two years, but other governments have adapted successfully.

For example, the UK Government bounced back from its failure to secure any offshore wind bids in its 2023 Contracts for Difference (CfD) tender round as it signed 5.3GW of offshore wind CfDs in latest tender round in September 2024; and German policymakers have navigated the changing market dynamics to award seabed leases for three offshore wind farms totalling 5.5GW in August.

No, the failure of the Danish Energy Agency to secure bids is due to more than overarching industry trends. In April 2024, experts warned in A Word About Wind that this tender was at risk of attracting low interest, even though 15 companies were reportedly in the running across the two phases at that stage.

They expressed three main concerns about the structure of the tender.

First, winning bidders would receive no financial support, even in the form of revenue stabilisation mechanisms, and would have to pay annual concessions to operate their offshore wind projects.

Second, the Danish government plans to hold 20% stakes in the projects. This has led to questions about whether the state might interfere in projects, which appears to have caused some uncertainty among developers.

And third, experts warned that the grid might not be able to cope with 10GW of projects, and the threat of curtailment or payments for new grid links. This is in addition to the negative power prices already facing operators in Denmark.

Of course, broader industry trends have had an impact on developers, who are now focused more closely on the viability of projects. But Danish policymakers and the Danish Energy Agency will need to reflect on whether they are asking too much of developers – and then change their approach if they want to make future tenders a success.

 

Tripodi talks

The challenges in offshore wind is a talking point in the latest edition of our Finance Quarterly digital magazine, published on Tuesday (10th December).

Cover interviewee Domenico Tripodi, partner and co-head of investments at AIP Management, discussed the clean-up underway in the industry as firms seek to ensure their projects make financial sense in a fast-changing market.

“There has been lots of clean-up in the sector,” he told us. “Take Ørsted for example. That is one of the players that said, ‘This doesn’t make sense so I’ll do my write-down and try to move on.’ But I believe there is much more dust under the carpet that has not come out yet. Some players have moved on with the investment decision no matter what.”

Tripodi warns these developments could “impact the overall profitability of the sector because, if the project happens, it will happen at a negative return”.

In that respect, we can see the lack of bids in last week’s Danish tender as a success of sorts for the industry, much like when developers sat out the UK’s 2023 CfD round. Companies are not bidding mindlessly to win offshore wind sites at any cost. Rather, they are looking at whether the risk-reward balance of new projects is right and refusing to bid if the numbers don’t add up.

This does not, to use Tripodi’s phrase, clean the “dust under the carpet” from existing schemes, but it does suggest that developers in the offshore wind industry want to ensure their future projects have a sound financial basis.

That should give us some Christmas cheer as the holiday period looms.

 

Join us to discuss investment in the offshore wind industry at ‘Financing Energy Transition 2025’ in London on 1st October. Book your place now