Iberdrola, Ørsted and RWE are among the developers involved in wake effect disputes at 20GW of UK offshore wind projects. The UK Government is now backing a 12-month study by the University of Manchester to assess the financial impacts of wake effects and find the best locations for projects.
Few things make your home life more miserable than a long-term dispute with your neighbours.
Neighbourly disputes are happening more often in offshore wind as more projects are being crammed closer together. Iberdrola, Ørsted and RWE are among the developers now battling on multiple fronts in UK waters, primarily about the impacts of wind wake effects on nearby schemes. Wake effects are when winds passing through one wind farm affect the wind resource a nearby project, and thus its energy output and financial performance.
The UK Government is now working out how to most effectively consider the impacts of wake effects in the planning system to minimise disputes. This was historically dealt with outside the planning system until a precedent was set in 2023 in a dispute related to RWE, Stadtwerke München and Siemens Financial Services’ Awel y Môr offshore wind project in the Irish Sea. This development consent order said turbines could not be built until RWE had assessed and mitigated the impacts of wakes on the 90MW Rhyl Flats project by RWE, Green Investment Group and Greencoat UK Wind.
Now the government-backed ORE Catapult is among organisations backing a national review by the University of Manchester into offshore wake effects. The study was announced last week and is due to launch officially at an event on 15th April. It is supported by Arup, the Crown Estate, EDF and RWE, and is funded by the Engineering & Physical Science Research Council.
The study will use advanced forecasting models to assess both operational projects and those due to complete by 2030. It has four key aims:
This work is due to last a year and is timely because around 20GW of projects in UK waters are now affected by disputes about wake effects, otherwise known as ‘wind theft’. The phenomenon is seen in other parts of the world too. It was also studied in a paper by scientists at the University of Bergen in Norway in 2022. This study found that offshore wind farms could reduce the wind resource of a neighbouring project by 20% and affect projects 50 miles away; and other research has shown wake effects can extend up to 65km.
By understanding wake effects better, governments and the industry can help resolve disputes more quickly between neighbouring projects.
Arguments and legal battles over wake effects and ‘wind theft’ are becoming more common in the UK.
This week, a row between Iberdrola and RWE has gone public after Iberdrola subsidiary Scottish Power demanded that RWE should mitigate impacts from the 1.1GW Five Estuaries project on the 960MW East Anglia 2. Iberdrola said East Anglia 2 could see a 0.5%-2.1% fall in annual energy production due to wake effects from RWE’s Five Estuaries and is demanding compensation.
In response, RWE accused Iberdrola of double standards because it was not aware of moves to compensate for wake effects from East Anglia 2 on either the Galloper or Greater Gabbard. Galloper is wholly owned by RWE, while Greater Gabbard is owned by RWE and SSE in a 50:50 joint venture.
This case is interesting as it shows the complex impacts of UK offshore wind projects on each other as the seas become more crowded, and also calls into question when wake effects should be considered in the planning process. Compensation for wake effects could have a big impact on returns at a project, but can only be modelled accurately when a developer knows the turbine model it will use and how those turbines will be laid out.
But this is not the only case. RWE is in dispute with Ørsted about the potential impacts of RWE and Masdar’s 3GW Dogger Bank South project in the North Sea on four projects in Ørsted’s 8GW Hornsea complex, which are at various stages of development and operation.
Separately, Ørsted has raised concerns about potential wake losses at Hornsea due to Corio and TotalEnergies’ 1.5GW Outer Dowsing project.
And EnBW, Cobra Group, BP and Flotation Energy have been in dispute with Ørsted over how would impact six Ørsted wind farms: the 90MW Barrow, 90MW Burbo Bank, 258MW Burbo extension, and the three projects in the 1.1GW Walney complex. These wake effects would come from EnBW and BP’s 3GW Morgan and Mona schemes; and the 480MW Morecambe development that Copenhagen Infrastructure Partners agreed to buy from Cobra and Flotation Energy last month.
As well as the Manchester study, there is also debate in the industry about the accuracy of wind wakes.
For example, in January, K2 Management argued in this blog that wake effect modelling is becoming significantly more accurate, and that arguments about the inaccuracy of wake effect modelling is harmful for the industry. Developers may face losses and have to make compensation due to ‘wind theft’, but models are accurate and becoming more so.
Clearly this is a huge issue, and will only get bigger. Offshore wind farms are getting larger and more numerous, while profit margins have been tightening in the last five years. This means these disputes will happen more often and have bigger financial impacts on companies less able to cope with losses.
The good thing is that developers are all in the same situation: sometimes they are the victim of wake effects and sometimes the cause of them. That means there is a vested interest in companies working together to solve these issues, to find best practice, and to avoid long and costly legal battles.
When neighbours in the wind industry can work together, they can overcome practical problems.
Join us at Financing Energy Transition and our other upcoming events